Business Insurance Auditing Services
Cut Your Insurance Premiums 25–35% - Without the need to change Agents
Our insurance cost experts uncover hidden costs, redundant coverages, and premium markups buried in your current policies. Using our proprietary benchmarks and carrier negotiation strategy, we help you reduce premiums while maintaining or improving your coverage.
Incorrect or Outdated Tariffs
Duplicate or Hidden Fees
Charges for Inactive Services
Estimated or Faulty Meter Readings
What Is a Business Insurance Audit?
An business insurance cost audit is a comprehensive review of your business insurance programs — including property, casualty, health, auto, and liability coverage — to identify overcharges, redundant premiums, and negotiation opportunities.
At P3 Cost Analysts, we combine decades of category expertise with powerful benchmark data from hundreds of insurance programs. We analyze your coverage structure, broker commissions, and carrier relationships to uncover savings while ensuring you remain fully protected.
Most clients reduce their total insurance spend by 25–35%, with no coverage dilution or need to change their preferred agent.
What We Audit
Our specialists conduct a detailed analysis of your current insurance portfolio. We focus on:
Policy Terms & Limits:
Reviewing deductibles, exclusions, and unnecessary endorsements and current loss ratios. Employe benefits structure to improve outcome for employer and employees.
Renewal Process Review:
Evaluating timing, transparency, and negotiation tactics used by your agent. Value here is more in educating…why your renewal date may be working against you etc. We want to educate you how to be an efficient consumer once we leave.
Carrier Access:
Ensuring your broker is bringing true and full market competition.
Coverage Optimization:
Confirming policies are optimized/designed for your business and risk profile.
Commission & Fee Structures:
Identifying hidden broker incentives.
Benchmarking:
Comparing your current rates and terms against our proprietary pricing database.
The result is a fully optimized, fairly priced, and strategically structured insurance program.
Why Insurance Premium Costs Creep Up
Insurance programs often increase year over year — even when nothing changes operationally. Without regular market testing and negotiation, you may be paying more than necessary Here’s why expenses rise over time:
Agent Incentives:
Agents are paid a percentage of premium — the more you pay, the more they earn.
Limited Carrier Access:
A single broker can’t quote all carriers, nor do they have the best relationship with all carriers, limiting competition and pricing power.
Hidden Commission Structures:
Carriers often embed broker overrides and bonuses into premiums.
Lack of Market Benchmarking:
Without comparative data, “renewal” rates are rarely validated.
Coverage Overlap:
Policies can double up on coverage that add cost without added protection.
Without structured oversight, these costs quietly compound year after year.
Our Proven 4-Step Process
15-minute call to assess your current program, our process, and potential
savings
We gather policy information and current benchmarks to drive negotiation with little to no heavy lifting for our client.
We leverage our industry expertise to bring in multiple
carrier options and negotiate best-in-market pricing.
20-minute meeting with results, deeper discussion can be two hours, to review savings options, strategize next steps, and celebrate the results.
Engagement model: Contingency-based. You pay only if we produce savings.
Benefits You Can Expect
25–35% average reduction in total insurance expenses
Zero risk – no savings, no fee
No disruption to existing agent relationship
Enhanced coverage clarity and carrier transparency
Proven negotiation tactics backed by benchmark data
Who We Help
We partner with organizations of all sizes that carry business insurance policies in: changed order
- Group Health & Employee Benefits
- Property & Casualty
- Commercial Auto & Fleet
- Professional Liability (E&O / D&O)
- General Liability & Umbrella
- Workers’ Compensation
If you spend over $150K per year on premiums, or have over 100 employees on their Benefits plan, we can likely deliver significant savings.
Frequently Asked Questions
How is P3 Cost Analysts different from an insurance broker?
We are independent consultants — not agents. We work for you, not the carrier. Our focus is cost reduction and coverage optimization, not selling
policies.
Do I have to change my agent or carrier?
No. Many clients keep their existing relationships. We simply ensure your policies are competitively priced and properly structured.
How much time does the process take?
Typically, less than two- three hours of your time from start to finish. We handle all of the heavy lifting.
Are there any upfront costs?
None. We only get paid if we find and implement savings.
What kinds of insurance can you audit?
We review all commercial insurance lines including but not limited to property, liability, auto, workers compensation, D&O, cyber etc. We also review your Employee Benefits program as well.
How much can I expect to save?
Most clients save 25–35%, with some achieving even greater reductions depending on their market and structure.
Related Services
Utility Auditing (Electric, Water & Gas)
Telecom Auditing(Phones & Internet)
Waste & Recycling Auditing
Merchant Processing Auditing
Uniform & Linen Auditing
Managed Print Auditing
Small Parcel Shipping
Maintenance Contracts
Ready to see how much you’re overpaying for insurance?
Schedule your free Business Insurance Audit today.
No upfront cost. No obligation. Just transparency — and benchmark-proven savings.
